Search WWW Search GoodspeedUpdate.com
MEDIA
Michigan Daily
Ann Arbor News
University Record
Michigan Radio
WCBN, WEMU

AREA BLOGS
Goodspeed Update
Arbor Blogs
Ann Arbor Is Overrated
Black at Michigan
Richard Murphy

Past the College Grounds
Sam Woll
Steven Cherry (Ypsi)
The Bunker (Ypsi)
Larry Kestenbaum
Edward Vielmetti
Chetly Zarko
Airbeagle
Andrew Vanalstyne
Neoliberal Chopping Block
Michigan MBA
Mouse Musings
Jenny Nathan
Matt Hollerbach
Bob Goodsell
Stephen Darwall

Common Sense Liberals
John Honkala: First City (Chicago)
Washington Oculus (D.C.)
Dave Enders (Baghdad)
Jim Secreto (China)
Josh Wickerham (China)
Ben King (Atlanta)
Juan Cole (Mideast)


MORE MEDIA
Ann Arbor Indymedia
Moment
Consider
Michigan Review
Mich Magazine
Every Three Weekly
BusinessDirect Weekly

Detroit Free Press
Metrotimes
Detroit News
Crain's Detroit
Michigan Indymedia
Michigan Chronicle
Michigan Citizen
Local 4 - WDIV
DetNow 7 - WXYZ

MLIVE.COM
MI AP Wire - Freep
MI AP Wire - MLive

New York Times
Washington Post
Los Angeles Times
Chicago Tribune
Omaha World-Herald
Top U.S. Newspapers
MSNBC.com

U-M NEWS
Admin News
LSA News
ITCS News
MGoBlue.com
UMHS News
Engineering News

Michigan Today Mag
LSA Mag

CAMPUS LABOR
Borders Readers United
Graduate Employees' Organization
Lecturer's Employee Organization
American Association of University Profs.
Students Organizing for Labor and Economic Equality

WORLD
Reuters
Al Jazeera English
Times of India
The Age (AU)

BBC News
The Guardian (UK)
Times of London
The Independent (UK)

MORE BLOGS
Tom Tomorrow
Jim Hightower
Nathan Newman
Paul Schmelzer
Beyond Brilliance
Ted Rall
Aaron Hawkins
Where is Raed? (Baghdad)
Matt Drudge
Jim Romenesko

Michigan Blogs
Detroit Blog

BEAT BUSH IN '04
Wesley Clark
Howard Dean
John Edwards
Dick Gephardt
John Kerry
Dennis Kucinich
Joe Lieberman
Ralph Nader
Al Sharpton

AROUND THE WEB
ZNet
ACLU, ACLU-MI
Open Secrets
The Onion
Memory Hole
Cryptome
Snopes
WhiteHouse.org
Porto Alegre
UN
Labor Start
Arts and Letters
UnderReported.com

ARCHIVES
April04
March04
February04
January04
December03
November03
October03
September03
August03
July03
June03
May03
April03
March03
February03 (Feb. 18-22)
January03
December02
November02
October02
September02
August02
July02
June02
May02
April02
March02
February02
January02
December01
November01
Sept.-Oct01

ADVERTISEMENTS


NEWS

Monday, October 20, 2003

The director of the LSA Honors Program, Prof. Stephen Darwall, responds to my viewpoint in a letter to the editor today, arguing that the Perlman Honors Commons is just the same as the RC's Benzinger Library. This seems to obfuscate the situation - the Benzinger doesn't have a huge sign over the door reading "Residential College Library" - it is, in fact, designed for the use of all residents of East Quad, as is appropriate for a residence hall library. Located at the heart of campus, it seems to me the Perlman Commons should be logically open to all students.

And to clarify, in my viewpoint I never claimed the honors program has closed the commons to non-honors students. The program does, however, do many small things to try to ensure only honors students use the lounge: the sign above the door reads "Honors Commons," the door is left slightly ajar, and only honors students are told to study there. What I asked in my viewpoint was that the commons be "formally opened to all students." What might that look like? Perhaps a simple sign taped to the door reading "Perlman Study Lounge. Open to all students for quiet study, M-F 9-5"

Here's the letter:

"To the Daily:

One day before his viewpoint criticizing the Perlman Honors Commons appeared in the Daily (Perlman Honors Commons dishonorable, 10/16/03), Rob Goodspeed defended the Residential College's Benzinger Library against a (rumored) University closing on his weblog (www.goodspeedupdate.com), saying that the library "serves as a resource for the Residential College: RC professors put ... materials on reserve there, and the library has hosted a variety of artistic and educational events in the past." The Benzinger Library is a resource for the RC in precisely the same sense that the Perlman Honors Commons is a resource for the Honors Program. Each exists primarily to support the activities of its respective program. The Honors Commons' function is to provide a site for honors seminars in its internal classroom, for intellectual events such as the Fresh Ideas symposium I host biweekly, for events planned by the Honors Student Steering Committee, for meetings between honors faculty and students, for student meetings, for student (and faculty) study, and for informal conversation. As for access, Goodspeed is simply mistaken when he says that access is restricted to honors students. Although the primary function of the commons is to support Honors Program activities, we have not found it necessary to restrict access to serve that function. Of course, unlike the Benzinger Library we have a central location, so we can't guarantee that that will always be so. Finally, I would like to clarify a misunderstanding about our admissions process. It is true that this year we will be able to make use of the University's new application materials (with new essay questions and teacher recommendations) to get a better sense of our applicants, including their intellectual seriousness and curiosity, but it is just not true that before the program relied entirely on grades and test scores. The program also took account of other factors, including, like University admissions, race, in order to build a more diverse class. We are in complete agreement with Goodspeed about the importance of that goal.

Stephen Darwall

Director, LSA Honors Program"


Posted by Rob at 5:30 AM
WHAT'S HOT

Inside the Daily
U-M Earnings
Political Giving
Michigamua
BAMN
MSA
My Course

Ann Arbor Cool Cities Task Force
Our Voices Count
Anti War Action!


UMICH
Google
Daily Jolt
U-M Directory
MIRLYN
Lexis-Nexus

mail.umich.edu
ITCS Account Usage
MPrint
IFS Space

Recent Crime
Campus Information

Wolverine Access
Coursetools
(CTNG)
LSA Courseguide
Advice Online
Rate My Professor
ITCS Status (CAEN)

Construction Info
Sculptures Info
Student Policies

EVENTS

(Continue list)

Ticket Master Events: Ark, Blind Pig, Hill Auditorium, Michigan Theatre, Power Center Also see: UMS events, and Current's Lectures, Readings, and Forums

Movie Times
MUTO Events
UM Campus Events
CURRENT's Calendar Ann Arbor Observer
MChalk.com

ONSITE
Borders Strike
Campus Shame
Planada
City Council Elections (Voting)
NAKED MILE
HASH BASH
CRIME ALERTS
BOOKS
CRITICAL FILES
PERSONAL PAGE
CAMPUS TOURS
9.11.01
GU MAINE
MICHIGAN DAILY
SURVEILLANCE
NETPD
PALESTINE CONF.
HADDAD
GANNETT PROGRAM
HOROWITZ
DAILY BOYCOTT

TEXTBOOKS
DogEars.com
Online Student Marketplace
Student Book Exchange
Cordx.com
Half.com
Shaman Drum
Union Bookstore
Michigan Book + Supply
Ulrich's

DORMS
Dining Hall Menus
TV!
Telephone
FIXIT Request

JOBS
U-M Jobs
U-M Student Employment
Career Center

A2 "PLANNING"
City Planning Dept.
Peter Allen
New Course
Ecology Center

STATEWIDE:
MI Land Use Leadership Council
MI Land Use Institute

Ann Arbor
Detroit/A2 Craigslist
A2 Local Market
MLive Town Talk
Local Sites Via GeoUrl
Ann Arbor District Library
City Government

STUDENT POLITICS

Student Orgs
MSA
RHA
LSASG
EQGA
UMEC

ACLU
ADC
AWA!
Dems
CR's
GEO
Greens
PIRGM
SOLE
SSAA
SFC
Students Allied
SFL
Zionists


NEWS ALERTS
<1 email per week
SITE INFO

Rob@ Goodspeedupdate.com

Atom XML Feed

AIM: RobGoodsp

Policies

PAY/DONATE: Paypal or Amazon

Technorati Profile

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?